By Robert Passikoff

According to Brand Keys, the New York-based brand and customer loyalty engagement research consultancy, in February 2012, Facebook ranked number 1 of 10 social networking brands included on the Brand Keys Customer Loyalty Index that received mentions from the 49,000 consumers polled.

It’s completely consumer-driven. First you need be resonant enough with consumers to make the list. Then we’re able to determine how well a brand meets or exceeds expectations consumer hold for the drivers of engagement and loyalty in the category. Five months ago Facebook was doing just fine.

Facebook falls from #1 to #5

But since the troubled IPO the brand has fallen from number one to number five according to overall brand engagement assessments, tied with LinkedIn, and just behind Twitter and YouTube. That’s on an overall basis. Diagnostically they lost connection and friendly engagement in two of the four category drivers that consumers use to make decisions about where their loyalty, time and money will go. p>The IPO damaged Facebook in terms of ‘Self-Image,’ showing a loss of 11% on that driver, and ‘Trust & Security,’ showing a loss of nearly 20%. The other drivers – ‘Ease of Connection’ and ‘Brand Value & Content’ – were relatively unchanged. Still, brand erosion on the other two was significant enough to move Facebook down the list. What was once a community is now being viewed as a business, and that changes things substantially.

Pinterest appears in #3 Spot

The marketplace, particularly the social network marketplace, travels at the speed of the consumer, with new entries all the time. In Brand Keys’ recent research, Pinterest, showed up for the first time. With that “change in the brand set the rankings change too.

Brand Keys Customer Loyalty Engagement Index May 30, 2012

1. YouTube

2. Twitter

3. Pinterest

4. LinkedIn

5. Facebook

6. Yelp

7. MySpace

8. Four Square / Google +

9. Flickr

10. Quora

In the re-configuration of the category Google+ took a hit too, moving from 5th to 8th. Yelp moved up one spot and MySpace moved down one. The latest official report from Google is that more than 100 million people have been active on Google + in the past month. But that number includes people who've set up Google + accounts and visited other "socially enhanced" parts of Google, like search or YouTube.

A new study from Brand Keys, a national study examining 83 categories and 600 brands, demonstrates unequivocally that not only does digital platform engagement differ by category, but also when it comes to digital marketing, one-size-does-not-fit-all.

Sure, there's a widely held notion that Google+ users, for example, skew male and tech-savvy, but that’s just more demos and segments, and figuring out how to locate the right consumer is pretty much the last thing brand marketers struggle with today. In social networking they need to manage their brand within the context of Main Street, not just Wall Street, and know as much as they can about what drives their category. Or they risk consumers turning very unfriendly very quickly.

About the author

Robert Passikoff is Brand Keys founder and president.

Brand Keys